How To Make S’mores With a Twist

S’mores are a delicious and gooey treat that’s perfect for summer nights spent around the campfire. But what about making them inside? There are so many delicious twists on s’mores that you can make in the comfort of your own home, from swapping out the traditional marshmallows for something like ice cream to adding delicious toppings like caramel sauce and strawberries.

In this post, we’ll show you how to make the most delicious and creative s’mores with a twist. We’ll provide step-by-step instructions for each of the recipes, as well as suggestions for the best ingredients to use. From traditional s’mores to something a bit more unexpected, there’s something for everyone here. So grab those graham crackers, chocolate bars and whatever else you need!

Ingredients

Traditional S’mores Ingredients

To make your traditional s’mores, you will need the following ingredients: graham crackers, marshmallows and chocolate bars. Stack two pieces of graham crackers together, then place one piece of chocolate and one melted marshmallow between the two graham crackers.

Non-traditional Ingredients

To give your s’mores a twist, you can add additional ingredients such as peanut butter, chopped almonds, Nutella, or various fruits such as strawberries or coconut flakes

Instructions

Gathering and Prepping Materials

Begin by gathering all the necessary materials for making your s’mores. Preparing all of them beforehand will make the process smoother and more efficient. If you plan on adding extra ingredients such as peanut butter or Nutella, it is best to spread them on your graham cracker before stacking them together to ensure an even distribution of the added ingredient. Also keep in mind that if you’re planning on making multiple variations of s’mores with different ingredients, it may be helpful to label each of them too (e.g. “PB+C” for peanut butter and chocolate).

Making Traditional S’mores

Once you prep all materials accordingly, begin by setting up your circular fire pit and ensure that it’s stable and secure before beginning to build your s’mores. To do this, stack two pieces of graham crackers together with one piece of chocolate bar in between them (tip: pre-break the chocolate bar into several pieces beforehand for easier handling). Note that the type of chocolate bar used will affect the final taste. For those who prefer a sweeter s’more, opt for milk chocolate instead of dark chocolate bars. Once you toast your marshmallow to your preference over the firepit, stick it between your graham cracker like a sandwich.

Adding the Twist

For those looking to really wow their guests with their homemade s’mores, here are some tips and ingredients to add more adding your toasted marshmallow:

To ensure even distribution of the extra ingredients across all s’mores variations made, stack two pieces of graham crackers together with a layer of Nutella/peanut butter in between them before topping with a piece of chocolate bar and one marshmallow.

Variations of the Recipe

Below are some uniquely delicious twists you can add to your homemade s’more that are sure to impress each guest at your campfire night or party.

Peanut Butter Cup S’more

This classic combination tastes just as satisfyingly delicious here inside your homemade s’more! Swap out traditional chocolate for fluffy peanut butter cups for a unique flavor.

Fruit S’more

Add some bright flavors to your homemade campfire treat by adding your favorite fruits such as berries like strawberries or raspberries. Consider substituting regular graham crackers for lemon-flavored cookies as well.

Coconut and Almond S’more

Perfectly sweet yet slightly nutty flavors take center stage when you sprinkle some coconut flakes and crunchy almonds inside your traditional s’more.

Serving Ideas

Grab and Go Style

For those looking for small bites on-the-go style snacks, consider serving them up individually wrapped up in parchment paper tied with twine for easy portability.

Deconstructed S’mores

For those looking to serve their delicious creations family style at their campfire night gathering, consider setting up a deconstructed s’mores station where guests can assemble their own unique variation according to their own taste preferences. You could also make a large pan or sheet with a graham cracker crust that’s topped with marshmallow filling and chocolate flakes or drizzles.

Ice Cream S’more Sandwich

For an even more indulgent treat that is sure to wow at any event, replace your typical marshmallow with ice cream (whatever flavor you like). You can also dip half of the graham crackers in melted chocolate and let them set up before assembly.

Conclusion

From traditional s’mores to something a bit more unexpected and creative, you now have all the tips and tricks you need to make the most delicious s’mores with a twist. So the next time you gather around the campfire (or couch), surprise your friends and family with some gooey fun with your homemade s’mores — with a twist!